Project X – Evaluations

1) Visual Communication:

In what ways does the visual communication/message of the piece meet the needs of the brief?

I think the message is clear and concise, asking people to recycle more and using a welcoming tone of voice, with shock elements too. The display aims to inform and educate the audience by being interactive and and inviting to engage with.

In what ways does the visual communication/message of the piece fail to meet the needs of the brief?

The display ended up being a very mixed bag of messages, with mainly came from errors in communication within the group. The design may seem too light hearted and upbeat for quiet a negative image were were trying to portray.

 

 

 

What are the strengths of the visual communication? Why?

I think some elements worked well, for example, the fish that could hang from the fishing rod on the display. Warping the text to a shape was an interesting way to engage the audience, encouraging them to read the little fact from the display, appealing to their inquisitive nature. I also like the “don’t be a tosser” type effect, although in hindsight, the choice of typeface may have been more appropriate to the negative nature of the topic.

What are the weaknesses of the visual communication? Why?

Tone of voice wasn’t in keeping with the overall gloomy topic. I think we tried to use a bright colours to try and attract the audience, but sacrificed the feel of the design, and the direction it should go in.

In what ways could the piece be mis-read or mis-understood by the audience? Be specific about who the audience is.

The tone of voice implied positivity of quiet a negative issue. This was a mistake and could have been rectified by working more efficiently as a group.

In what practical ways could the piece be developed or improved?

I think the group attitude could have been better, and work harder to complete the designs, communicating more effectively to marry each element up, and plan more without being distracted by time constraints.

I also think darker, gloomy colours should have been used to try and evoke a negative reaction. Ultimately, we could have shown both sides of the argument more effectively, using bright colours on one half of the argument, and darker colours on the other side.

2) Good Design? Evaluation

Please note you are asked to describe and make analysis of your thoughts and actions about the topics below. If you have been able to act upon your considerations of Good Design you should give reasons for your design decisions. If you have not been able to act upon your considerations, nevertheless give reasons for this and reflect upon your thoughts about the actions you would have liked to have taken further. Honest evaluations are required as this reflection is to help you move forward.

  

In what ways did you consider Designing Backwards or application of Systems Thinking to your project?

We started by looking at the overall picture of systems thinking in this project, looking how altering one element in the eco-system can have a massive knock on effect. This was then applied to the project thinking about how we could make a difference from people recycling more to keep waste from entering the ocean.

In what other ways have you considered the sustainability of your project process and outcomes?

It has been interesting to see the large problems in the world through this project, and has got us thinking about how we as designers can make a difference. Not only have we been asked to design visuals in this project, it’s also been about designing an experience for the end user.

In what ways have you considered the ethical implications of your project process and outcomes?

We had empathy with our audience and know not everyone likes having the message rammed down their throat, showing glum visuals of what the world will end up like if no solution is found. During the inital visual display, it was clear our audience wanted to know how they could make a difference. It was important to show both sides of the argument, adding an educational dynamic.

In sustainability and ethical terms in what ways was your work in this project an improvement or a backward step for you as a socially conscious designer?

I think this has been a forward step in my attempt to become a socially conscious designer. This project has encouraged us to think about our local community and look at how we can make a difference changing how we live and treat the world.

What targets can you make at this point for your work in the future as a socially conscious designer?

I think in terms of this project, we needed feedback from our local community on the designs to help strengthen them. I thought this was a good way to get real time reaction on a design. Sampling the target audience can help generate new ideas, and get an insight on how they respond to the visual signifiers.

3) Reflection of own working practices:

Be very honest with yourself in this section. Please feel free to approach a member of staff for help finding ways to develop skills.

How was my time keeping?

I won’t lie, its been hard trying to juggle everything. A lot of late nights, however I didn’t miss hardly any class time and was in when I said I would be.

How was my analysis of the brief?

Initially, I found it difficult to understand the brief, but felt enlightened after a session with Tim during the first couple of weeks on Project X. After getting my head around the issue, and what the end deliverable could be, I think I gained a good understanding of what our audience wanted to see.

How was my research?

During the research phase, I felt I communicated well with the audience and asked a lot of questions to help enhance the display, and get real time reactions to what they saw from the visuals we produced. However, as identified in an earlier post, our questions on the feedback form were quite closed, encouraging one or two word answers, which was a mistake on our part. Despite this, we gained constructive feedback on the design.

I also carried out a lot of research outside of college hours, taking a trip to Brighton to view the #streetsahead initiative, encouraging people to be more conscious of where they place there waste, cleaning up the city and preventing plastics entering the ocean. I looked at other case studies too to enhance my knowledge.

How did I draw conclusions from my research?

I reflected at the end of each blog post, analysing what I’d learnt from each piece of research undertaken. I feel this has been one of my strengths during this process, is having empathy with the audience and taking data and direction from the source first hand.

How did I use research to generate and develop ideas?

We did this in the form of feedback forms, showing our display to the audience and asking for feedback to help strengthen them later. This was an important part of the design phase, as it was almost like getting a cheat sheet of what it was they wanted to see and get from the design.

How did I use evaluations to help with my ideas generation and development?

I used evaluations at the end of each blog post to help distill the main points of how this relates to the project and what I could do to help strengthen it. It was important to understand how each part of the design process was going to relate to Project X, something I struggled with in the early weeks as I didn’t really understand!

How did I use experimentation during the project? How can I make this more effective?

I used experimentation when showing the audience the display before the final submission, which helped us understand what it was they wanted to see. I think, however, I could have used it more throughout the design process, using prototypes to fully understand how it could work.

In what ways did I show that I had achieved the Learning Outcomes? How can I improve this next time?

I evidenced everything in my blog, and kept checking the learning outcomes to make sure I was on track.

What parts of the project did I enjoy most? Why was this the case?

I actually really enjoyed working closely with the community and getting reaction to the display. I also found it fascinating seeing how other people and groups used different methods to display there message. A lot of interactivity was going on!

What parts of the project did I enjoy least? Why was this the case?

Working in a group! On this occasion, I’ve found it difficult to communicate effectively.

At what times did I work best? Why might this be the case? How can I ensure that I work well at all times?

I think I worked well when I fully understood the direction we were going in. I think in future, I need to work on getting more clarity before moving forward in the design phase.

What areas inspired me? Why was this the case? How could I follow these up?

A lot has inspired me in this project, but for me and in relation to my topic, Ocean waste, I found the Brighton initiative #streetsahead interesting, and was amazing to see a real life campaign in the public eye, so local to me.

What areas were challenging or difficult? Why was this the case?

Working in a group as stated earlier. Also understanding the brief initially.

How can I go about developing and improving the parts I found difficult?

Take more of a leadership role in group projects, and communicate more effectively.

Do I need to develop certain skills? Do I need these now? Or later?

I think I need to be more confident in my ability. This is something I’ve only recently discovered.

 

 

 

Advertisements

Charity – Good Design Evaluation

  • In what ways have you considered the sustainability of your project process and outcomes?

The majority of what will be sent out by the client will be screen based, keeping paper to a minimum. However, in future there are likely to be flyers and other marketing material that will be sent out to local residents. The creation of the logo was very sustainable, and the outcome will also have benefits to the local area.

  • In what ways have you considered the ethical implications of your project process and outcomes?

The project is giving my services for free to a local charity. They aim to do good for the local area, and feel that both during the process, and the outcomes I have come to are benefitting the area.

  • In sustainability and ethical terms in what ways was your work in this project an improvement or a backward step for you as a socially conscious designer?

I think this project has benefitted me the most in terms of developing my social consciousness as a designer. It has enabled me to work with the local community, and show empathy to their problem and providing an effective solution.

  • What targets can you make at this point for your work in the future as a socially conscious designer?

I want to be able to show my clients empathy and work with them closely in order to create the best outcome. In this project, I’ve found it hard to communicate with my client at times, and this may have hindered my process slightly. In future, I’d like to try and keep more regular contact, and extract more information from the client.

Dungeness Bomb Project – Good Design Evaluation

  • In what ways have you considered the sustainability of your project process and outcomes?

I thought this project was a great way to look at new landscapes and generate ideas. We were able to get out in the open and be creative, without being destructive to the environment. It was interesting to see the contrasting environments, and the weather played a big part in creating the mood. The postcards made in this project are one off pieces aiming to promote the area.

  • In what ways have you considered the ethical implications of your project process and outcomes?

The postcards might attract more visitors and therefore may destroy the local environment. They also may become litter if a lot sold, and would have a negative impact on the environment.

  • In sustainability and ethical terms in what ways was your work in this project an improvement or a backward step for you as a socially conscious designer?

I think this project has been great to make me a more socially conscious designer. Its enabled me to get outdoors and experience different environments. The images produced for the postcards are snapshots of my experience on that day.

  • What targets can you make at this point for your work in the future as a socially conscious designer?

I want to remember the open and free feeling when we were in Dungeness. The environment generated so many ideas, and we were able to relax and let our creativity shine. This could be used as a tool of inspiration for future projects.

Summer Brief – Good Design Evaluation

  • In what ways have you considered the sustainability of your project process and outcomes?

My design would only be printed a few times, and therefore there wouldn’t be a lot of paper wastage.

  • In what ways have you considered the ethical implications of your project process and outcomes?

The design is to promote a local cup final, creating spreads for a match program. This is an informative piece of design, that is a one off event.

  • In sustainability and ethical terms in what ways was your work in this project an improvement or a backward step for you as a socially conscious designer?

I haven’t really moved forward much as a socially conscious designer as a result of this project, as I didn’t look into the sustainability of my product.

  • What targets can you make at this point for your work in the future as a socially conscious designer?

I want to be able to find more ethical and sustainable ways of printing, that ensures consistency and quality, whilst also being able to be mass produced.

KSA – Good Design Evaluation

  • In what ways have you considered the sustainability of your project process and outcomes?

The logo is going to be used mainly onscreen, meaning there will be no paper to just throw away. The client will be able to use the logo on onscreen PDF documents, and also a website.

  • In what ways have you considered the ethical implications of your project process and outcomes?

The client is trying to give a resource to students and local businesses, and the logo is to demonstrate this benefit. I would say this has positive ethical implications.

  • In sustainability and ethical terms in what ways was your work in this project an improvement or a backward step for you as a socially conscious designer?

It was a step forward I would say. I was able to think about the positive benefits to the local area, whilst also keeping waste to an absolute minimum by not printing.

  • What targets can you make at this point for your work in the future as a socially conscious designer?

I think using onscreen formats benefits both the client and the target audience, with convenience being key. I’ve always been print focused, however, recently I’ve developed stronger online skills, so maybe I should consider this in future projects.

Conspiracy Theories – Good Design Evaluation

  • In what ways have you considered the sustainability of your project process and outcomes?

I used black and white throughout my design, making it a two colour process and less ink.

  • In what ways have you considered the ethical implications of your project process and outcomes?

I would say if this project was put into the public eye, it would generate fear in the local area. Using photoshop to alter images and presenting it to the public as genuine evidence wouldn’t be very ethical.

  • In sustainability and ethical terms in what ways was your work in this project an improvement or a backward step for you as a socially conscious designer?

I would say this project is perhaps a backwards step, as I didn’t really consider how my project could be made more sustainable other than the inks used. I also wouldn’t agree with the message I would be sending as a graphic designer, giving false evidence.

  • What targets can you make at this point for your work in the future as a socially conscious designer?

I would consider using other materials to print my design on. I did consider using recycled paper, however after speaking to tutors, I found out that the process is actually very environmentally unfriendly, wasting loads of water and energy.

FMP – Good Design Evaluation

  • In what ways have you considered the sustainability of your project process and outcomes?

I considered all options when thinking about the sustainability of my book. However, I came to the conclusion that paper isn’t as destructive as everyone thinks, as trees are replanted and specifically grown for paper. My book is only being printed a few times, with a small amount of pages, so the impact on the environment is small.

  • In what ways have you considered the ethical implications of your project process and outcomes?

I considered what the problem was, and aimed to educate students on healthy dieting and trying to get them to engage in healthy eating. I would say the ethical implications would be positive to my audience.

  • In sustainability and ethical terms in what ways was your work in this project an improvement or a backward step for you as a socially conscious designer?

I would say it has made me engage with my audience, making me aware of an issue within the food market, and producing an educational tool for them to use.

  • What targets can you make at this point for your work in the future as a socially conscious designer?

I would perhaps consider other sustainable methods of printing, maybe exploring vegetable inks, or using a cheaper, easily reproduced method of printing.